Lancaster’s Historic District Rules: Upgrading Windows Without a HARB Headache
If you live in one of Lancaster’s Historic Districts, your home’s exterior represents a snapshot of Lancaster’s rich history that deserves to be protected. That’s why replacing your windows comes with more strings attached than you might expect.
Every visible exterior change on homes in the historic districts is reviewed by Lancaster’s Historical Architectural Review Board (HARB), which aims to protect the unique character of these neighborhoods. And while that oversight is important for preserving the city’s architectural identity, it can also be a challenge for homeowners trying to make home upgrades.
At Zen Windows of Central PA, we can help historic homeowners successfully navigate the HARB review process by learning what home upgrades get approved and what tends to get kicked back.
Below, we’ll break down what “in-kind” replacement means, what HARB expects from applicants, and how to navigate the system with fewer surprises.
Why Homeowners Replace Historic Windows in the First Place
Lancaster has two major preservation zones: the Historic District and the Heritage Conservation District. HARB’s job is to oversee exterior updates in both of these neighborhoods in order to keep these homes’ historic facades intact.
Windows and doors are important aspects of a home’s exterior, especially when it comes to preserving Lancaster’s architectural history. For this reason, HARB prefers that homeowners retain as many of a home’s original windows as possible. At the same time, there are plenty of practical reasons why a homeowner may want to upgrade their windows:
Security, Comfort, and Performance
Many homeowners find that their historic windows are drafty, hard to open, or allow too much moisture inside. Rotted sashes, broken locks, and rattling panes are not only a nuisance but an indicator that your windows are no longer secure or weather-resistant.
Boosting Home Value and Curb Appeal
Restoring or replacing old windows in a way that complements the historic design not only satisfies HARB but also adds long-term value to your property. Buyers in Lancaster’s historic neighborhoods often look for homes that have already passed HARB review, which can streamline resale and increase appeal.
Replacing your windows doesn’t mean giving up your home’s charm.
When done right, a window replacement can improve your home’s energy performance and security while keeping the original style intact. Plus, with options like custom sash kits, you can keep your historical appearance without sacrificing modern convenience.
When a HARB Review Is Required
HARB reviews any exterior work that alters a building’s appearance in terms of design or materials. It does not include interior work or exterior painting.
For window replacements, this includes projects that involve visible sashes, frames, or trim. If you’re simply repainting or repairing existing elements, you probably won’t need a formal review. But anything involving material change or size modification will almost always go to the board.
What HARB Looks For in Window Replacements
Even subtle changes in window appearance can disqualify your proposal. A different sash configuration, altered frame depth, or switching from wood to vinyl could all lead to a rejection, even if the new window functions much better.
“In-Kind” Replacements Preferred
When HARB refers to an “in-kind” replacement, they’re talking about a product that matches the original window in material, size, shape, and appearance. This doesn’t mean you have to use the same manufacturer or settle for outdated technology, but it does mean that a wood window should be replaced with another wood window that mimics the original look from the street.
Beyond materials and configuration, HARB will look at how your new windows will fit in alongside neighboring properties. Even slight visual mismatches can stand out on a cohesive block. Things like trim width, sill angles, and muntin placement all matter. HARB wants replacements that blend in, not stand out.
Modern Vinyl Window Replacements Usually Get Denied
Modern full-frame vinyl windows may look clean and functional, but they almost never match the look of original wood windows.
- Vinyl frames are typically thicker, which changes the visual balance of the facade.
- Muntins are often glued on instead of built into the window.
- The shiny plastic finish contrasts heavily with the natural materials found in older homes.
These differences can be enough for HARB to reject a replacement outright, even if the product is new and energy-efficient.
Custom Sash Kits Often Get the Green Light
What Is a Custom Sash Kit?
A custom sash kit lets you replace the working parts of a window without removing the original frame. This method maintains the surrounding trim and casing while giving you new, efficient glass and smooth functionality. The result is a fresh window that looks nearly identical to the original from the outside.
Because the frame remains untouched, sash kits typically meet the city’s definition of an “in-kind” upgrade. Most people from the sidewalk won’t notice a difference in your windows, even when the energy efficiency and reliability have completely changed for the better.
How Sash Kits Compare to Vinyl
When you stack a sash kit next to a full-frame vinyl unit, the differences are clear. Vinyl frames are bulkier, the finishes are synthetic, and the sightlines change. Sash kits—especially in wood—preserve the visual integrity of the opening and let you keep important exterior details like the sill and casing.
Real-World Tips for Navigating HARB Review
Plan At Least One Month Ahead
HARB usually meets on the first Monday of every month, and applications are due at least two weeks before each meeting. Once HARB has reviewed your application, they’ll send a recommendation to the city council. Receiving a “Certificate of Appropriateness” for your project can take another few weeks depending on the city council schedule. We recommend budgeting at least a month for the approval process. So if you’re hoping to install in late spring, get your paperwork in by early March.
Include Detailed Before-and-After Comparisons
Photos, detailed measurements, and product brochures are your best friends. Take pictures of your current windows from the street and explain how your replacement meets the city’s “in-kind” criteria. It helps to include side-by-side visuals that highlight matching elements like muntins, sash operation, and frame proportions.
Focus on Visual Compatibility
HARB is focused on how your window looks, first and foremost. Don’t submit generic vinyl brochures or include language about “maintenance-free” materials without clarifying appearance. Also, skip any mention of installer certifications unless it’s specifically requested. And never assume that being energy-efficient is enough to win approval on its own.
How Zen Windows Helps You Stay Preservation-Friendly
We Know What the Board Wants: Our team understands HARB’s expectations and can help guide you through solutions that meet their standards. We’ve seen which materials and methods get approved and which ones don’t. Let us help you prepare a smarter submission from the start.
No Pressure, Just Real Advice: Our products sell themselves—we don’t do sales pitches or fake promotions. You can get a straightforward quote by email, with no deposit or in-home sales visit required. We’re here to provide solutions, not sell you something you don’t need.
Explore Our Custom Sash Options: We’ll show you products that combine visual compatibility with modern performance. And when you’re ready to start your HARB application, we can help provide everything you’ll need for the board.
If you’re planning a window replacement in Lancaster’s historic districts, talk to Zen Windows Central PA first. We’ll make sure you stay on the right side of HARB without losing sleep over specs, forms, or facade guidelines. Request your free quote today to find out how easy window replacement can be, even in a historic neighborhood.
Disclaimer: All information on https://zenwindows.com/ is published in good faith and for general information purposes only. Zen Windows does not make any warranties about the completeness, reliability, or accuracy of this information. Any action you take based on the information you find on this website is strictly at your own risk.